Story image

Researchers probe psychology behind phishing attacks

28 Feb 18

What makes the difference between a successful phishing attack and an unsuccessful one?

That is just one of the questions posed by two researchers at Carnegie Mellon University in the US in a study that created an experiment to see exactly which phishing strategies work.

Prashanth Rajivan and Cleotilde Gonzalez conducted the research in a study titled Creative Persuasion: A Study on Adversarial Behaviors and Strategies in Phishing Attacks.

The study states that cybercriminals will attempt to act as a trustworthy third party in social engineering attacks designed to trick people into downloading malicious attachments or to visit fake websites.

The researchers had three questions: What role do incentives play in determining phishing effort and success; does individual creativity predict success in phishing attacks;  what, and how strategies are implemented in successful phishing emails.

They created an experiment in which 105 participants acted as phishing attackers and scored points for successfully deceiving 340 other participants who were the recipients.

The experiment was played in turns and was designed to train and award participants for trying different phishing methods.

“To evade detection participants were encouraged to edit and modify the content of their phishing emails, so that they would explore the effectiveness in each attempt,” researchers explain.

In determining the role incentives play in determining phishing effort and success, they found that participants who received rewards for their efforts early on were more likely to exert more effort.

There was no evidence of individual creativity predicting success in phishing attacks.

However, when researchers analysed what phishing strategies are used and how they are implemented, they discovered substantial findings.

There were several different tactics that could potentially result in phishing success: an authoritative tone, an expression of shared interest, sending notifications, and communicating failure, and pretending to be a friend all proved to be successful tactics.

Phishers used email tactics including deal offers, selling illegal material sales and those that used a positive tone didn’t fare so well.

“Participants who received phishing examples that contained work-related and social communications, were more successful with their attacks,” Rajivan and Gonzalez explain.

They found that attackers who stick to certain strategies may be more likely to persuade victims to respond to emails.

“Attackers who discover effective strategies and who are persistent in their attempts to making them work would be more successful in persuading end-users to respond to their phishing emails. Our results also suggests an effect of phishing inspiration on phishing success,” they continue.

The experiment did not provide consider spear phishing as it did not supply phishers with any specific details about the targets.

The researchers say future work in the field could open up understanding of human behaviour in the context of spear phishing attacks.

“These insights may be used to inform tools and training procedures to detect phishing strategies in emails,” Rajivan and Gonzalez conclude.

Oracle Java Card update boosts security for IoT devices
"Java Card 3.1 is very significant to the Internet of Things, bringing interoperability, security and flexibility to a fast-growing market currently lacking high-security and flexible edge security solutions."
Sophos hires ex-McAfee SVP Gavin Struther
After 16 years as the APAC senior vice president and president for McAfee, Struthers is now heading the APJ arm of Sophos.
Half of companies unable to detect IoT device breaches
A Gemalto study also shows that the of blockchain technology to help secure IoT data, services and devices has doubled in a year.
Huawei founder publically denies spying allegations
“After all the evidence is made public, we will rely on the justice system.”
Malware downloader on the rise in Check Point’s latest Threat Index
Organisations continue to be targeted by cryptominers, despite an overall drop in value across all cryptocurrencies in 2018.
IoT breaches: Nearly half of businesses still can’t detect them
The Internet of Thing’s (IoT’s) rapid rise to prominence may have compromised its security, if a new report from Gemalto is anything to go by.
Carbon Black: What does cybersecurity have in store for 2019?
Tom Kellerman has shared five insights for the year ahead, including a particularly bold one.
Hands-on review: The Ekster Wallet protects your cards against RFID attacks
For some time now, I’ve been protecting my credit cards with tinfoil. The tinfoil hat does attract a lot of comments, but thanks to Ekster, those days are now happily behind me.