SecurityBrief Asia logo
Asia's leading source of cybersecurity and cyber-attack news
Story image

Germany watchdog calls out Facebook's 'abuse of power'

FYI, this story is more than a year old

Germany's antitrust regulator Bundeskartellamt has ruled that Facebook can no longer combine German citizens' user data from multiple sources – something that could come as a tipping point for the social network and wider data collection practices across the internet.

As of December 2018, Facebook had more than 2.32 billion monthly active users. It also has a ‘dominant position' as a social network in Germany, with 32 million monthly active users and 23 million daily active users.

Currently Facebook's terms and conditions allow the company to collect user data in the platform itself, as well as platforms including Facebook-owned services such as WhatsApp and Instagram. However, Facebook can also collect user data beyond those platforms – from smartphone apps and across the internet.

Bundeskartellamt asserts that Facebook must ask for consent from all users to collect data from within Facebook-owned services and third party websites – or face heavy restrictions on data collection.

Facebook's ‘abuse of power'

According to Bundeskartellamt president Andreas Mundt, Facebook's unrestricted data collection helped to build unique user databases and also helped it to abuse its dominant position in the market.

“The Bundeskartellamt's decision is not about how the processing of data generated by using Facebook's own website is to be assessed under competition law. As these data are allocated to a specific service users know that they will be collected and used to a certain extent. This is an essential component of a social network and its data-based business model.

Bundeskartellamt explains that any third party websites that include Facebook ‘Like' or ‘Share' integrations report data back to Facebook.

“It is not even necessary, e.g., to scroll over or click on a “Like” button. Calling up a website with an embedded “Like” button will start the data flow. Millions of such interfaces can be encountered on German websites and on apps.

Even if there are no Facebook integrations, users' data can still be tracked if the website owner uses Facebook Analytics.

While there is a business case for Facebook's services as ‘free of charge' to users and the attractiveness of the platform as an advertising space with rich user data, it must still obey the rules.

Facebook Ireland's head of data protection Yvonne Cunnane and Facebook director and associate general counsel Nikhil Shanbhag wrote in a blog post that they disagree with the Bundeskartellamt.

They believe that Facebook already complies with GDPR regulations.

"Facebook has always been about connecting you with people and information you're interested in. We tailor each person's Facebook experience so it's unique to you, and we use a variety of information to do this – including the information you include on your profile, news stories you like or share and what other services share with us about your use of their websites and apps," they wrote in a blog.

They also believe data sharing and collection can also prevent terrorism, child exploitation, and election interference.

“By combining data from its own website, company-owned services and the analysis of third party websites, Facebook obtains very detailed profiles of its users and knows what they are doing online,” says Mundt.

Bundeskartellamt adds that Facebook's conduct represents exploitative abuse – and dominant companies should not use these tactics to the detriment of its consumers.

Now Facebook can no longer carry out unrestricted collection of non-Facebook data and apply it to user accounts,” Mundt continues.

“In future, consumers can prevent Facebook from unrestrictedly collecting and using their data. The previous practice of combining all data in a Facebook user account, practically without any restriction, will now be subject to the voluntary consent given by the users.

“Voluntary consent means that the use of Facebook's services must not be subject to the users' consent to their data being collected and combined in this way. If users do not consent, Facebook may not exclude them from its services and must refrain from collecting and merging data from different sources.

Bundeskartellamt says its decision is not final and Facebook has one month to appeal the ruling.

Shanbhag and Cunnane say they will continue to defend Facebook's position and that the Bundeskartellamt simply cannot single out one company.

"This is the point we'll continue to make to the Bundeskartellamt and defend these important arguments in court, so that people and businesses in Germany can continue to benefit from all of our services. We'll also continue finding ways to improve the controls we offer and safeguard people's information," they conclude.

Security experts comment

Quest's principal technology strategist, Colin Truran

“Nothing is for free, so we always need to ask ourselves, “why am I not being asked to pay for this, what's in it for them?” What's more concerning is that without truly knowing what the information we are providing is being used for we would not know its true value and therefore are we being ripped off?  Just look at the profits of these super providers offering these free to use services and ask that question again.

“It's great to see that progressive authorities such as Germany's competition regulator is taking a stance on this free-for-all data pillage and at the very least, bringing some much-needed attention to the problem.  I hope other authorities around the world will take a similar view.  I'm not anti-Facebook or any other social media organisation, I just want the users to not lose ownership of their identity and freedoms as a result.”

Cliqz GmbH general manager Dr. Marc Al-Hames

“Facebook is only number two. By far the most important data monopolist is Alphabet. With Google search, the Android operating system, the Play Store app sales platform and the Chrome browser, the Internet giant collects data on virtually everyone in the Western world. And even those who want to get free by using alternative services stay trapped in Alphabet's clutches: With a tracker reach nearly 80 percent of all page loads Alphabet probably knows more about them than their closest friends or relatives. When it comes to our data, the top priority of the market regulators shouldn't be Facebook, it should be be Alphabet!"

Related stories
Top stories
Story image
Cybersecurity
Video: 10 Minute IT Jams - An update from SearchInform
Val Novoselova joins us today to to discuss new trends in the information security space, and how SearchInform is adapting to some of the new trends we are seeing.
Story image
Secure Code Warrior
Secure Code Warrior announces Coding Labs innovation
Coding Labs mechanisms allow developers to move from learning to applying secure coding knowledge more efficiently, leading to fewer code vulnerabilities.
Story image
Phishing
Vectra Protect team finds Microsoft Teams vulnerability
The Vectra Protect team identified a post-exploitation opportunity in August, allowing malicious actors to steal valid user credentials from Microsoft Teams.
Story image
Cybersecurity
StackHawk launches deeper API security test coverage
Expansion of test coverage includes custom scan discovery, custom test scripts and custom test data for REST APIs.
Story image
Ransomware
Absolute recognised in KuppingerCole Leadership Compass 2022
The company's Absolute Secure Access was recognised for its ability to protect users and resources while improving the remote worker experience.
Story image
Observability
Virtualisation Security Market to reach over $7 billion by 2032 - report
A new report from Future Market Insights has found that the Virtualisation Security Market is anticipated to reach a valuation of US $7.6 billion.
Story image
Software Defined Wide Area Network
Versa Networks recognised as Leader in Magic Quadrant for SD-WAN
The company has been positioned as a Leader for its ability to execute and convey completeness of vision in the Magic Quadrant.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Cyber security incidents more common in APAC - report
Chief financial officers in the Asia Pacific are woefully uninformed about their company's cyber security risks, according to a new report.
Story image
Compliance
Security and compliance challenges halt innovation strategies
"What’s needed is a new mindset and a fresh approach, one in which security and compliance are continuous and actually speed innovation."
AWS Marketplace
Whitepaper: A practical guide for mitigating risk in today’s modern applications
Link image
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence in cybersecurity - Future Market Insights
It is projected that revenue through the software segment in the AI in the cybersecurity market will grow at 15.8% CAGR during the forecast period. 
Story image
IoT security
Nozomi Networks and WALLIX strengthen OT network security
By combining WALLIX and Nozomi Networks solutions, end-to-end visibility and traceability for maximum security in an industrial environment is provided.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Confidence in security challenges of hybrid work improving
84% of IT professionals have some degree of confidence in their user access security systems to enable remote work securely and easily, up from 56% in 2021.
Story image
Malware
SonicWall threat report mid-year update highlights significant threat variance
The 2022 SonicWall Cyber Threat Report mid-year update from SonicWall gives an in-depth insight into many of the current trends across the threat landscape.
Story image
Software-as-a-Service
Varonis unveils new security features for Salesforce admins
Data security firm adds one-click permissions comparison and analysis features for Salesforce admins, saving them time while improving security posture.
Story image
Cryptocurrency
Crypto giveaway scams continue to soar, according to report
There's been a fivefold increase in the number of domains used for crypto giveaway scams that involve fake YouTube streams in the first half of 2022. 
Story image
Malware
August's top malware: Emotet knocked off top spot
FormBook is now the most prevalent malware, taking over from Emotet, which has held that position since its reappearance in January.
Aws Marketplace
Learn how to implement a backup and recovery plan for a new generation of Kubernetes-based modern applications
Link image
Story image
Phishing
Barracuda adds Zero Trust Access to enhance email security
The new capabilities allow customers to control access to email systems and Microsoft 365 applications on a need-to-know basis, enhancing email security.
Story image
Security vulnerabilities
Claroty finds seven vulnerabilities in Dataprobe iBoot-PDU
The Claroty research team (Team82) has found seven vulnerabilities in Dataprobe's iBoot-PDU, the company's intelligent power distribution unit product.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Aqua Security solution to stop software supply chain attacks
Development and security teams can now proactively address the most critical software supply chain risks from code through runtime.
Story image
Ransomware
Commvault unveils early warning system, Metallic ThreatWise
A first among data protection vendors, the new cyber deception service detects and contains ransomware threats.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Test your API Security with Infinite API Scanner
The effectiveness of API scanning technology can mean the difference between successful and unsuccessful programming outcomes, and often enterprises and IT leaders struggle to get it right.
Story image
Distributed Denial of Service
Reevaluating DDoS protection for a changing threat landscape
DDoS attacks are gaining in frequency, intensity, duration, and complexity, with attackers employing more vectors
Story image
Enterprise
Delinea shares the importance of PAM, partners and security for modern enterprise
Identity-based security is becoming a crucial tool for modern enterprises as they continue to adapt to different working environments.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Hands-on review: Yubikey 5C NFC
Founded in 2007 and specialising in computer and network security, the Swedish company Yubico is now a leader in global authentication.
Story image
Digital Transformation
Report highlights gaps in trust between enterprises and consumers
ISACA defines digital trust as the confidence in the integrity of relationships, interactions and transactions among providers and consumers.
Story image
Partnerships
Concentric AI, Snowflake to enhance data security posture
The integration benefits joint customers by making Concentric AI's data security posture management capabilities readily available on the Snowflake Data Cloud. 
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
ForgeRock announces next gen identity orchestration capabilities
ForgeRock has launched identity orchestration capabilities to enable enterprises to deliver improved user experiences secured by threat protection.
Story image
Cloud
Netskope launches enhancements to cloud firewall solution
Netskope has announced key enhancements to Netskope Cloud Firewall, the firewall-as-a-service (FWaaS) component of its converged SASE platform.
Story image
Cloud Security
CrowdStrike launches new partner program to expand routes to market
"We developed the CPSP program in partnership with GSIs, MDR vendors, MSPs, MSSPs and Telcos to ensure we were meeting their needs and empowering them."
Story image
IT infrastructure
Check Point Software Technologies launches new Horizon innovation
There is now a need for all organisations to have a security operations centre with 24/7 monitoring, response, and threat-hunting capabilities.
Story image
Customer Relationship Management
Why Managed Service Providers are the next big target
MSPs are now such an integral part of the digital ecosystem that companies trust more of their sensitive data with them
Story image
Malware
Absolute Software extends persistence technology to Trellix
Customers can benefit from Absolute’s firmware-embedded connection, ensuring that Trellix's endpoint protection solution remains effective and healthy.
Story image
Network Security
20/20 visibility key to improving network security
IT leaders around the world share a ubiquitous appetite for greater network visibility, according to a new study from Infoblox.
Story image
Data Protection
Barracuda adds web security in Zero Trust Access solution
The latest release of Barracuda CloudGen Access protects users from malicious web content and strengthens integration with identity providers.
Story image
Firewall
Barracuda tackles intensified threat landscape with latest releases
"The Barracuda XDR solution combines data across our security stacks through a single dashboard view, giving us the visibility we need."
Story image
Encryption
Entrust advances Sigma Instant Issuance Platform for cards
Unique light curing module for Entrust Sigma instant issuance systems brings new financial card durability and personalization to card issuers.
Story image
Software Defined Wide Area Network
Fortinet named Leader for SD-WAN in 2022 Gartner Magic Quadrant
The company has announced it has been positioned highest in ability to execute for two years in a row and recognised for completeness of vision.
Story image
Web Development
Oracle reveals and releases new Java 19 updates
Oracle has announced the availability of Java 19, which is set to deliver performance, stability, and security improvements for developers.