SecurityBrief Asia logo
Asia's leading source of cybersecurity and cyber-attack news
Partner content
Story image

The 5 most common multi-factor authentication (MFA) methods

By Tova Dvorin
Tue 7 Jul 2020
FYI, this story is more than a year old

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) became a mainstay of the mobile device industry over the past decade. If you've ever had to enter an authentication code, receive an SMS, or scan some hardware, you've interacted with an MFA-enabled system.

While MFA is ubiquitous, it's far from perfect – whether you're the business or the end-user. Here are the 5 most common MFA methods, and where each of them falls short. 

1. Hardware OTP (one-time password) tokens 

What are they? 

Hardware-based devices which generate one-time codes based on a cryptographic key stored inside the device. The same cryptographic key is also held by a server -- which can generate the same OTP to verify that the value provided by the user is correct.

User interfaces (UIs) can vary: common types include a physical token that presents a one-time password on a built-in screen, or a device with a keypad which require a user to enter a PIN code before a one-time password is displayed.

Common issues:

  • Poor user experience (UX) – users restricted in executing operations/verifying identity on-the-go, which is incompatible with today's always-on lifestyle 
  • High maintenance and operating costs – businesses require large staffs to handle support questions and a high budget for the deployment, maintenance, and upgrade costs for tokens
  • Tokens are vulnerable to theft or social engineering attacks (e.g. impersonation).
     

2. Standalone OTP mobile applications 

What are they?

In a word: authenticator apps.

Common issues: 

  • Poor user experience (UX) – users must switch constantly between apps to authenticate identity/transaction; user loses access with every change/loss/upgrade of their smartphone; no secure backup options 
  • Lack of support for businesses relying on third-party apps
  • Potential for maliciously-built apps to produce and then steal OTPs and impersonate their users.

 

3. Soft token Software Development Kits (SDKs)

What are they?

This is software that can be embedded into mobile apps and utilizes cryptographic operations to authenticate the user and device. These solutions usually provide a smoother UX; there's no need to switch between apps or rely on a hardware device. From a security perspective, there are significant advantages, as soft-token SDKs support advanced cryptography, e.g. digital signatures.

Common issues:

  • Poor user experience (UX) – users must switch constantly between apps to authenticate identity/transaction; user loses access with every change/loss/upgrade of their smartphone; no secure backup options 
  • Lack of support for businesses relying on third-party apps.
     

4. SMS-based OTPs

What are they? 

This is a user-friendly method that does not require users to install any app. Rather, in order to authenticate, a one-time password is sent by SMS to the user's registered phone, and this is used to authenticate them.

Common issues:

  • UX issues – OTPs often have a time limit, and limited mobile carrier reception can cause issues for users in remote areas. 
  • Vulnerable to malware, SS7, and SIM-swapping attacks. 
     

5. Smartcards and cryptographic hardware tokens

What are they?

Physical devices that can perform cryptographic operations like decryption and signing, while providing strong physical protection of the keys inside a fully isolated secure enclave. They can be used for logon to PCs (e.g. via Windows Smartcard Logon) as well as to digitally sign transactions to verify that the authentic user indeed authorized this specific transaction. Smartcards require a dedicated reader or may be contactless; cryptographic hardware tokens are typically connected via USB.

Common issues: 

  • Operational headaches for businesses – high cost of deployment, maintenance, upgrade, and replacement
  • Similar UX issues as OTP hardware tokens.

While each MFA method has its flaws, what you can see above is one single trend: a trade-off between security and usability.

There is hope, however – with cutting-edge cryptographic key storage and management methods built for enterprises.

To learn more about this cryptographic breakthrough, click here.

Related stories
Top stories
Story image
Cybersecurity
Spike in demand for cybersecurity training amid skills shortage
"Organisations cannot just rely on cybersecurity professionals to safeguard the businesses’ infrastructure and protect their data."
Story image
Malware
OpenText reveals nastiest malware of 2022, with Emotet at the top
OpenText threat intelligence experts combed through the data, analysed different behaviours, and determined which malicious payloads are the nastiest.
Story image
Cybersecurity
The growing threat of CEO fraud and how to mitigate it
By posing as the CEO or other senior figures, attackers guarantee that malicious emails get employees' attention. Many employees are reluctant to question a request from their CEO, so they usually provide the information.
Story image
Security Information and Event Management
LogRhythm announces LogRhythm Axon and new solution enhancements
According to the company, Axon provides an easier way for security teams to achieve better visibility across both cloud and on-prem log sources, helping further establish a foundation for their security practices.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Swift successfully pilots its Securities View capability
The new capability significantly increases transparency in post-trade processing while preventing costly settlement fails; it will be widely available in 2023.
Story image
Ransomware
Commonwealth tackling rising cybercrime threat in Asia
Ransomware, identity theft, and virtual security attacks identified as growing threats to security and economic growth.
Story image
Microsoft
Yubico research finds concerning trends around authentication security practices
A new global survey from Yubico has found that 59% of employees still rely on usernames and passwords as the primary method to authenticate their accounts.
Story image
Apple
Jamf shows intent to acquire mobile security firm ZecOps
This acquisition positions Jamf to help IT and security teams strengthen their organisation’s mobile security posture.
Story image
Work from home
Jamf showcases new products to simplify and secure work
At the 13th annual Jamf Nation User Conference, the company shared how its continuous product innovation is helping organisations succeed with Apple.
Story image
Mobile Device Management
How to easily scale your mobile workforce and devices for the peak shopping season
Retailers are under constant pressure to streamline processes and become more efficient while looking for ways to improve customer satisfaction levels.
Story image
Distributed Denial of Service
Sysdig reveals a loss of $53 for every $1 cryptojackers gain
The 2022 Sysdig Cloud Native Threat Report breaks down supply chain attacks against containers and how geopolitical conflict influences attacker behaviours.
Story image
Kaspersky
Cybersecurity loopholes prevalent in South East Asia
In terms of the share of vulnerabilities with publicly available exploits, three countries out of top five are located in Southeast Asia.
Story image
Edge Security
Security practices for modernising the “spaghetti” of on-premises IT
Many organisations are wondering how to securely modernise their workload, often made up of a “spaghetti” of on-premises applications and management consoles.
Story image
Malware
Mandiant uncovers malware ecosystem deployed on VMware hypervisors and guest systems
Mandiant research has uncovered a novel malware ecosystem that was found deployed on VMware hypervisors and guest systems by an advanced and suspected China nexus threat actor.
Story image
Data Protection
Cloudflare brings Data Localisation Suite to more APAC businesses
This allows any business in these countries to service their data locally while benefiting from the speed, security, and scalability of Cloudflare’s global network.
Story image
Partner Programmes
Trellix set to launch new unified partner program in 2023
"We co-developed the Xtend program with our partners to create the right business model for deploying Trellix XDR."
Story image
Data Protection
99% of security experts unhappy with tokenisation investment
Cybersecurity experts are looking for a solution that provides the strength of tokenisation while removing the friction that has accompanied it in the past.
Aws Marketplace
Learn how to implement a backup and recovery plan for a new generation of Kubernetes-based modern applications
Link image
Story image
Cybersecurity
Best practices for industrial cyber resilience
Operational technology (OT) security is gaining more attention than ever before, but sufficient understanding of what it takes to prevent breaches is still lacking amongst many organisations.
Story image
Microsoft
A deep dive into a Corporate Espionage operation
In the last few years, we have seen a dramatic shift in the level of sophistication of cyberattacks, mostly thanks to the introduction of the profit-sharing business model for financially motivated threat actors.
Story image
Threat intelligence
Trellix advances threat intelligence with new research centre
Trellix has announced the establishment of the Trellix Advanced Research Center to advance global threat intelligence.
Story image
Cloud Security
75% of AU companies had cloud security incident in past year
According to new Venafi research, complexity is due to increase, as companies plan to host more applications in the cloud.
Story image
Firewall
Barracuda accelerates growth in its data protection business
Barracuda cloud-to-cloud backup protects against evolving cyber threats, such as ransomware, and is now transactable in the Azure Marketplace.
Story image
Network Management
Fortinet introduces enhanced AIOps across its gateways
FortiAIOps builds on Fortinet's rich history of developing artificial intelligence to deliver actionable network insights for self-optimising management.
Story image
Ransomware
Delinea updates DevOps security, remote access more seamless
New enhancements include development support on the most recent Mac computers and improved secrets' management usability through automation.
Story image
Malware
Decrease in malware volume, but surge in encrypted malware
The Q2 Internet Security Report found office exploits continue to spread more than any other category of malware.
Story image
Cybersecurity
De-risking the innovation cycle – a modern, real-time approach to security
Many organisations see cybersecurity as an inhibitor of innovation, with burdensome protection measures standing in the way of progress and speed.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Employees unsure who to go to to report security incident
A new study shows more than 20% of the untrained global workforce do not know who to contact during a security breach.
Story image
Software-as-a-Service
Varonis adds secrets discovery to data classification
The data security firm announces enhancements that detect and remediate overexposed private keys, encryption certificates, API keys, and authentication tokens.
Story image
Enterprise
Delinea shares the importance of PAM, partners and security for modern enterprise
Identity-based security is becoming a crucial tool for modern enterprises as they continue to adapt to different working environments.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Ransomware attacks continue to increase, report finds
Nearly a quarter of businesses have suffered a ransomware attack, with a fifth occurring in the past 12 months.
Story image
Cybersecurity
Test your API Security with Infinite API Scanner
The effectiveness of API scanning technology can mean the difference between successful and unsuccessful programming outcomes, and often enterprises and IT leaders struggle to get it right.
Story image
Firewall
Forrester names Akamai as web application firewall leader
"We continually monitor and improve our capabilities to defend customers from new threats, while enabling customers to protect evolving attack surfaces."
Story image
Legacy
Trellix enables greater cyber resiliency with extended XDR platform
"Legacy SIEM technology has failed to modernise security operations. We are confident Trellix XDR fills this critical gap.”
AWS Marketplace
Whitepaper: A practical guide for mitigating risk in today’s modern applications
Link image
Story image
Hybrid Cloud
Hybrid cloud security driving need for deep observability
Gigamon is bringing application and network-level intelligence together to help network, security, and cloud IT operations teams eliminate security blind spots.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Fortinet advances AIOps to aid the hybrid workforce
"We’re continuing our commitment to AI innovation by delivering AIOps capabilities across our robust portfolio of enterprise networking technology."
Story image
Malware
Black Lotus Labs discovers new, multipurpose malware
Black Lotus Labs, the threat intelligence team at Lumen, has discovered a new, rapidly growing, multipurpose malware written in the Go programming language.
Story image
Virtual Private Network
95% of organisation rely on VPN as threats continue - report
There is a growing number of VPN-specific security threats and a need for Zero Trust security architecture in enterprise-level organisations.
Story image
Malware
Kaspersky uncovers new malicious malware NullMixer
Kaspersky researchers have uncovered a new malware stealing users credentials, address, credit card data, cryptocurrencies, and accounts.
Story image
Software-as-a-Service
Enterprises yet to fully commit to cybersecurity - CompTIA
“Digital transformation driven by cloud and mobile adoption requires a new strategic approach to cybersecurity, but this poses significant challenges."
Story image
Cloud
How modern IT architectures are moving beyond network visibility
Dealing with multiple cloud providers makes it difficult to identify security threats and performance bottlenecks and troubleshoot issues.